How to Spot Fake Signatures on Collectibles (And Protect Yourself from Getting Scammed)

Autographs are one of the most exciting parts of collecting—there’s something magical about owning a piece of history signed by your favorite celebrity, musician, or sports icon. But in a world flooded with forgeries, spotting fake signatures has become a crucial skill for any serious collector.

In this in-depth guide, we’ll show you exactly how to detect fake autographs, protect yourself from buying counterfeits, and build a collection you can be proud of.

🔍 Why Fake Signatures Are So Common

Let’s be real—autographs can command serious cash. A genuine signature from someone like Taylor Swift, Stan Lee, or Kobe Bryant can sell for hundreds or even thousands of dollars. That kind of money naturally attracts scammers.

Some fakes are laughably bad. Others are terrifyingly convincing. And in some cases, even the experts get fooled. That’s why you need to arm yourself with knowledge.

🧠 First: Understand the Types of Forged Signatures

Not all fakes are created equal. Here are the main types you’ll come across:

• Autopen: A mechanical device that "signs" using a real pen, often used by celebrities or politicians. Looks real but lacks pressure variation.

• Stamp Signatures: Literally a rubber stamp of a signature. Often used for mass-signed items.

• Pre-prints: A printed image of a signature—commonly found on posters or mass-produced merch.

• Forgeries: Straight-up fakes, hand-signed by someone trying to mimic the original.

✒️ Step-by-Step Guide to Spotting a Fake Signature

Here’s how to put your detective hat on:

1. Compare Known Authentic Examples

• Google is your best friend. Search for “[Name] authentic signature” and compare carefully.

• Look for:

  • Letter formation

  • Flow and speed

  • Consistency in pen pressure

💡 Pro tip: No one signs their name exactly the same every time, but there are consistent quirks. Forgers tend to get too “perfect.”

2. Check the Pen Pressure and Flow

• Real signatures have natural pen lifts and pressure changes.

• Fakes often look “flat,” shaky, or robotic—especially autopens.

• Use a magnifying glass or high-res photo to inspect.

3. Inspect for Stops and Hesitations

• A genuine autograph flows. Forgeries may have awkward pauses or “drawn” letters.

• Shaky or inconsistent lines are a red flag.

4. Look for Obvious Print Patterns

• If the “signature” has dot matrix patterns, it’s a pre-print.

• Hold it up to light to check for ink sheen—real ink reflects differently than print.

5. Use UV Light or Magnification

• Under UV light, real ink sometimes reveals stroke direction or pressure points.

• Magnifiers can expose mechanical replication or print dots.

🛡️ How to Protect Yourself from Buying Fakes

You don’t need to be Sherlock Holmes to avoid getting ripped off—just follow these golden rules:

✅ Buy from Reputable Sellers

• Look for top-rated eBay sellers, auction houses, or stores specializing in memorabilia.

• If you're on eBay, check feedback history and whether they offer a Certificate of Authenticity (COA).

✅ Always Demand a COA (But Be Cautious)

• A COA is only as good as the company behind it.

• Trusted names include:

  • PSA/DNA

  • Beckett (BAS)

  • JSA (James Spence Authentication)

  • West Coast COA 😉

• Avoid vague COAs from companies you've never heard of. Google them before trusting.

✅ Ask for Proof of Signing

• Photos or videos of the signing event are gold.

• Some sellers provide “in-person” (IP) provenance—ask for the backstory.

✅ Don’t Fall for the “Too Good to Be True” Trap

• If someone’s offering a Michael Jordan signed basketball for $50, run.

• Fakes often come with tempting prices. Stick with sellers who know the value.

✅ Use Trusted Forums and Communities

• Reddit’s r/autographs, autograph-specific Facebook groups, and niche collector forums can help vet a piece before you buy.

• Get second opinions—especially on big-ticket items.

🛠️ Tools That Can Help You Verify Signatures

If you’re serious about collecting, consider investing in tools and services like:

• Autograph reference books (many exist for musicians, actors, and athletes)

• UV flashlights

• Digital microscopes

• Subscription databases like PSA’s AutographFacts or Beckett’s Signature Review service

🚨 Real Stories: When Collectors Get Burned

Thousands of collectors have been duped—and some for big money. Just ask anyone who bought a “signed” Beatles LP on Craigslist or a supposed Elvis Presley autograph on a napkin.

One collector spent over $2,000 on a signed Nirvana album with a phony COA. It wasn’t until he posted in a collector group that he realized it was a forgery—and the COA was issued by a now-defunct company.

Moral of the story: Always vet the item and the authenticator.

✅ Final Checklist Before You Buy an Autograph

Before you click Buy Now, run through this quick checklist:

• Does the signature match verified authentic examples?

• Is there variation in ink flow and pressure?

• Do I know and trust the seller?

• Is there a legit COA?

• Have I checked with collector forums or second opinions?

If you can check all those boxes—you’re probably in good shape.

🎯 Bonus: Where to Find Real Autographs at Good Prices

Want to avoid the fakes and still score killer deals? Check out our handpicked, underpriced collectibles updated weekly:

👉 Explore WestcoastCOA’s trusted picks here

Or browse our affiliate links for authentic autographs on eBay (with commission support to keep guides like this going!):

🎯 eBay Authentic Autographs – Verified Sellers

💬 Join the Conversation

Have you ever been scammed—or narrowly avoided one? Tag us on X @WestcoastCOA and tell us your autograph horror stories or success finds.

Protect your passion, trust your instincts, and collect smart.

Want more insider autograph content like this? Join the WestcoastCOA newsletter for exclusive tips, eBay deals, and authentication deep dives!